Cash-Only in 2025? Here’s What Happened When I Tried It

Published
Category
Personal Finance
Cash-Only in 2025? Here’s What Happened When I Tried It
Written by
Avery Lane profile picture

Avery Lane, Founder & Chief Income Strategist

Avery Lane is the mind behind Top Money Maker, known for turning bold ideas into practical money moves. With real-world experience in side hustles and business systems, she helps readers build income with clarity, confidence, and strategies that actually work.

When I told my friends I was going cash-only in 2025, they looked at me like I’d said I was giving up Wi-Fi.

“Wait… no credit cards? Not even a debit?” “Nope. Just envelopes, ATMs, and good old-fashioned bills.”

I didn’t make the switch to be trendy—I did it because I wanted a reset. Somewhere along the way, even I, a so-called income strategist, was swiping out of habit. I was losing touch with my spending. And I figured the best way to get it back? Take it offline.

So I challenged myself to go 100% cash for 60 days—and here’s exactly what I learned, the benefits I didn’t expect, and what it taught me about money, discipline, and building real wealth in a digital-first world.

Understanding the Cash-Only Lifestyle

1. What It Really Means

Going cash-only doesn’t just mean using cash at the grocery store. It means no cards, no apps, no autopay. Every expense—food, gas, entertainment, bills—has to be covered with physical cash.

It’s not just a budgeting tactic. It’s a mindset. One that puts intentionality back into every dollar spent.

2. Why I Tried It

I’ve built side hustles, automated investments, and coached others toward financial independence. But when I reviewed my own bank statements recently, I realized I was swiping without thinking. Small charges were adding up—$9 here, $14 there—until suddenly I’d spent $400 on nothing I could remember.

So I decided to pull the plug and go full cash. And wow—did it shift the way I related to money.

Living Cash-Only in 2025: Can It Even Work?

Let’s get real—2025 is not exactly cash-friendly. But it’s also not impossible. Here’s how it went down.

1. The Challenges I Hit

  • Cashless businesses: Some places straight-up wouldn’t take my money. Trendy cafes, online shops, even my gym’s auto-billing system—all card-only.
  • Subscriptions: I had to cancel Netflix and Spotify (temporarily) since I couldn’t pay them in cash.
  • Bill payments: Some utility companies still let me pay at in-person kiosks. Others? Not so much.

I had to get creative. I used prepaid debit cards for the things I had to pay online—but I only loaded them with my weekly cash budget. It kept me on track without breaking the experiment.

2. Where It Worked Surprisingly Well

  • Groceries: I shopped with envelopes labeled “Food” and “Extras.” When the envelope was empty, I was done.
  • Local shopping: Farmers markets, thrift shops, and mom-and-pop stores welcomed my cash with a smile.
  • Dining out: I limited myself to two cash-based meals out per week. It made me savor the experience more—literally and financially.

The Unexpected Benefits I Didn’t See Coming

Going cash-only wasn't just about avoiding debt—it gave me a new relationship with money.

1. Real-Time Budgeting

When you physically hand over $20, it hurts more than tapping a card. That little sting? It’s a good thing. It makes you pause, consider, and prioritize.

I found myself:

  • Saying no to impulse snacks
  • Checking prices twice
  • Thinking, “Do I want this more than I want financial peace?”

2. More Control, Less Stress

Here’s the wild part: I felt more relaxed about money. Why? Because I knew what I had. I wasn’t second-guessing my balance or forgetting about pending charges.

With cash, there are no surprises. What you see is what you spend.

3. I Spent Less Without Even Trying

In 60 days, I spent 22% less than usual. Not from depriving myself—but from being more thoughtful. I saved over $500 just from cutting mindless purchases.

And bonus? I redirected that $500 into my Roth IRA. Thank you, envelope system.

Is a Cash-Only Lifestyle Actually Realistic Today?

Short answer: Yes—with boundaries.

1. You’ll Need Workarounds

  • Use prepaid cards for must-have digital expenses
  • Find businesses that support local economies—they often still prefer cash
  • Pay bills at cash-accepting payment centers (many grocery stores and pharmacies offer this)

2. You Can Customize It

Some people do 100% cash. Others use a hybrid model:

  • Cash for day-to-day spending
  • Cards for fixed bills and investments

That’s the model I’ve stuck with since ending my 60-day challenge.

Financial Wins From My Cash-Only Reset

Here’s what happened during those 2 months:

  • I saved $500+
  • I canceled 3 unused subscriptions
  • I meal prepped more
  • I stuck to my grocery budget for the first time in a year
  • I re-evaluated needs vs. wants without guilt

But the biggest win? I started spending in alignment with my values again. And that’s worth more than any budget line.

The Downsides (and How to Handle Them)

I won’t sugarcoat it—cash-only isn’t perfect. Here’s what bugged me and how I got around it.

1. Inconvenience

I had to plan my ATM visits. If I forgot, I was out of luck until the next day. Solution? Weekly cash runs every Sunday became part of my routine.

2. Limited Access to Online Deals

I couldn’t grab flash deals or limited-time offers online. That taught me one thing: if I didn’t need it enough to plan for it, I probably didn’t need it at all.

3. It Can Feel Socially Awkward

Pulling out exact change in a fast-paced checkout line felt weird at first. But then I realized—I’m managing my money. Not impressing anyone in line.

Should You Try It?

Not everyone has to go all-in on cash to benefit from this mindset. But even trying it for a week or two can change your spending habits for the better.

Here’s who I think should try it:

  • Anyone trying to get out of debt
  • Anyone who feels like their budget isn’t working
  • Anyone who’s constantly wondering, “Where did my money go?”

Financial Mastery Tips

  1. Start with a 7-day cash challenge: No cards, no swipes—just paper. Track what changes.
  2. Use the envelope method: Separate cash into categories like food, fun, gas, etc.
  3. Withdraw once a week: It limits impulse purchases and gives structure.
  4. Use prepaid cards for digital must-haves: Keep the convenience without the credit.
  5. Reflect weekly: Review what you spent, what you saved, and what you’d do differently next time.

Old-School Strategy, Modern Results

Going cash-only in 2025 may sound old-fashioned, but don’t underestimate it. Sometimes, stepping away from the convenience of tech is what gives you the clearest view of your finances.

It made me more intentional. More resourceful. And way more in control.

If you’re looking to reset your habits, cut back on mindless spending, or just reconnect with your money—consider giving cash a try. It might just be the unplugged solution to your most plugged-in problems.

Your wallet—and your future self—will thank you.

Was this article helpful? Let us know!